Posted on Aug 28th, 2009
by
mimi
RealQuestion? Is there such a thing? a question is only an inquiry based on observation or belief. WHAT IS THE INTENTION? - do you really want to know? or are you trying to bring up a subject to discuss, or just making conversation, or......
Whether you are the asker or askee, there will be a motive of some sort:
--what's the weather forecast for tomorrow?
- do you believe in God
- are you going to do the dishes?
- when are you going to grow up and take responsibility...?
After my brain injury, I took every question at face value. I could not read tone of voice and facial expression. So the question, "Mom, are you going to do the dishes?" became a puzzle when my son asked me. We were sitting in my living room having coffee, and he asked me that. I was confused. Why was he mentioning dishes? Dishes were in the kitchen. Did he mean am I going to do them NOW? I wasn't because we were here talking. I was wracking my brain trying to figure out an appropriate answer. Time was passing and I wasn't coming up with anything. I became stressed.
So it turns out, that my son really wanted to know if I wanted him to either help me do the dishes, or else he would do them if I wasn't going to in a reasonable (?) time period (?) that existed in his mind. But I know that only in retrospect-- after he explained it all to me. Which took a lot of time listening and figuring out again.
Why not ask me directly? - do you want me to wash the dishes now/help you wash the dishes now? Then I could have answered yes or no and it would have been very simple.
Maybe real questions are the ones that can be answered with words like Yes, No,
Maybe, I Don't Know.....hahhaha like how often is THAT going to happen! or "I think it's going to rain tomorrow, but I could be wrong",
Maybe a Real Answer t is more crucial than a real question.... but who can judge?
I don't know ;>)
Access: Public
Print
views (134)